Welcome to Brothers Pizza & Pasta
Brothers Pizza & Pasta, located at 253 Benner Pike in State College, PA, is a cherished local eatery known for its delicious, traditional Italian fare. Renowned for its flavorful pizzas—particularly the sought-after Sicilian style—this establishment delights customers with generous cheese combinations and a delectable crust. Among its many offerings, the ham triple decker sandwich has received high praise, showcasing their commitment to satisfying taste buds. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with attentive service that keeps patrons coming back. Brothers Pizza & Pasta is a staple for anyone craving authentic Italian comfort food at reasonable prices.
Brothers Pizza & Pasta: Reviews & Ratings
I had the best ham triple decker sandwich ever! Tre layered it perfectly, it looked and tasted great! Super Job
I visited this pizza spot on an out of town business trip. I was introduced to Brothers pizza on my lunch break. I have to say I was highly impressed. Being a Philly native I wasn't sure what to expect, but I was pleasantly surprised! The pizza was so flavorful, on the thin side how I like, but the cheese combinations and crust were delicious and I usually don't eat crust! Please stop by it's so worth it! Reasonable prices as well, you won't be disappointed!
A State College tradition ....sneaky hard to get into ....simple seating ...fast hot good food ....consistenly good...can get busy...solid good old school italuan pizza place
Very nice place! I arrived late to pick up my to go order and the food was still warm when picked up. The staff were very nice. They had very good customer service. The garlic roll was amazing, probably one of the best I’ve ever had. The pasta was also very good.
Have gotten take out many times from here and have to say, the Sicilian pizza is the best in town (I always get it with extra sauce). The service has been prompt and friendly each time. Consistently great experience coming here.
This place is a hidden gem in the area. My father and I went on a road trip and found this place to eat lunch. The male waiter was awesome and attended to us every time. The place was busy but we felt like we were taken cared of. Food didn’t take long to come out. My dad recommends the turkey sub sandwich and I recommend the chicken Parm. Don’t forget to ask for the garlic rolls because they are to die for.
This is specifically just for the Benner Pike location. We have a Brothers in Milesburg across from the high school that i will not go to anymore because of the quality, the quality sucks at that location. Benner Pike is always good, ive never had a bad meal at that location. My wife and I are GM and Assistant Manager at a Papa Johns so i do know restaurants i do know pizza i do know quality. Todays visit was perfect everything came out just as it should and they used sliced Roma tomatos not cubed tomatos. I think Romas are the best tomato for a pizza specially white pizza. Im thankful for this restaurant because we have stopped eating at so many other restaurants purely over quality. All my reviews quality is the number one thing i talk about because it can have no atmosphere but it wouldnt matter to as long as the quality is there. I highly highly recommend this locale for dining.
Excellent pizza. Highly recommended. 8.48 for lunch special. Two delicious slices and a beverage until 4 pm.
Location
-
253 Benner Pike, State College, PA 16801, United States Hotline: +1 814-234-4200
Welcome to Brothers Pizza & Pasta, a beloved gem nestled in the heart of State College, Pennsylvania. Located at 253 Benner Pike, this establishment has earned its reputation as a local staple, serving up comforting, authentic Italian fare that warms the heart and satisfies the palate. With a simple yet inviting atmosphere, Brothers Pizza & Pasta manages to capture the essence of an old-school Italian eatery while providing a modern dining experience.
The offerings at Brothers are truly remarkable. Many fans rave about the ham triple decker sandwich, noted for its perfect layering and vibrant flavor profile. This sandwich showcases the kitchen's attention to detail, making it a must-try for anyone visiting. The pizza, often described as a culinary delight, features a thin crust beloved by many, including Philadelphia natives. The combination of flavorful cheeses and a crust that is crisp yet tender elevates it to another level. As one diner stated, it's so good, you'll find yourself enjoying the crust, which is a rare feat!
One of the standout dishes reported by patrons is the Sicilian pizza, highly praised for its extra sauce and consistent quality. This mouthwatering delight is complemented by prompt and friendly service that keeps customers returning time and again. Additionally, the garlic rolls boast a reputation of their own, described by diners as “probably one of the best” they've ever tasted—always warm and freshly made.
Brothers Pizza & Pasta proves to be an ideal spot for both casual lunches and hearty dinners. Quotes from satisfied customers reflect the establishment's commitment to quality and customer service. It's not uncommon to see it bustling with activity, which speaks volumes about the experience awaiting every customer.
This homey joint makes for a fulfilling visit, combining traditional tastes with consistent execution. Whether you're looking to enjoy a meal on-site or grab some takeout, Brothers Pizza & Pasta is undeniably worth your time. With reasonable prices and a menu that doesn't disappoint, you’ll leave feeling satisfied and eager for your next visit.